stack of mattresses bed with red bedspread bed with brown bedspread blue and white mattress

Colgate Classica I Foam Crib Mattress Review

It would be difficult to find a better baby mattress than the Colgate Classica I foam crib mattress. Colgate for kids is a trusted brand in the crib mattress industry, and its Classica I is one of the most recognized and popular crib mattresses in the US. Let's find out why.

When you are shopping for a crib mattress for your new baby's crib, you are welcoming a new member of the family, and this is naturally a very exciting time. But try not to let the excitement get the best of you.

Buying a crib mattress takes time and caution since your new baby deserves not only the best but also the safest product around.

What are its best features?

The Classica I foam mattress from Colgate won the #1 spot in all crib mattress tests conducted by leading publications. So what does the Classica I have that makes it better than other crib mattresses?

  • Extra firm foam
  • Lightweight
  • Hypoallergenic and eco-friendly
  • Waterproof
  • Strong and reliable construction
  • Breathability
  • Easy maintenance

Health, safety, and comfort in one

The strong suit of the Colgate Classica I foam crib mattress is the foam itself. Colgate uses a special extra firm foam that offers several advantages:

Safety: It is not advisable to use extra soft mattresses for babies since they don't have the ability to push themselves off the mattress in case they get turned over. This is why you need an extra firm mattress that will keep your baby in his current position and will not cause him to accidentally turn over.

Health: The firm foam is recommended by many medical experts due to its ability to provide much-needed ideal orthopedic support for your baby's young spine.

Comfort: The firm foam does not compromise comfort despite its firmness.

No burden

The Colgate Classica I foam crib mattress is no burden to use. You can easily lift it up for cleaning or arranging since the crib mattress is extremely lightweight.

Clean mattress, green environment

Babies can be extremely sensitive to allergens. To protect your baby, you need a hypoallergenic crib mattress like the Classica I.

Other than fending off allergens, the mattress is also environment-friendly. Like all Colgate mattresses, it is Greenguard Certified.

Bring on the waterworks

Babies can't often be kept from wetting their beds or spilling water or milk. If your crib mattress is not the Colgate Classica I, the frequent moisture can shorten its life span. The Classica I, however, is waterproof, so the wetness won't affect the durability of your mattress at all.

Created with care

The USA-made Colgate Classica I is created with utmost care from Colgate's mattress designers. The ultra durable foam is covered by a triple layered cover made of tear-resistant vinyl. The mattress is also held together by super strong seams thanks to the added cloth binding. The product has also passed all federal standards in terms of safety and flammability.

Keeping your baby cool

Look closely at the Colgate Classica I and you will see distinct eyelet vents. These allow air to flow freely through the mattress to maintain the mattress' freshness and keep your baby cool and comfortable all night long.

No hassle

Maintenance of the crib mattress is a breeze. Just wipe it clean with a warm moist cloth dipped in water and mild soap. Regular cleaning can help maximize the life of your crib mattress.

Awards and recognitions

The Classica I is a consistently top-rating product in most crib mattress reviews and studies conducted by different consumer-oriented publications. It has won an award from iParenting Media and gained the Excellence in Retailing recognition from NINFRA. It has also been recommended on the Baby Bargains book.

On top of those, it has also gained the approval of various parenting associations such as:

  • First Candle Sids Alliance
  • JPMA
  • Baby Furniture Association

Crib Size Considerations

The Classica I is designed to fit standard crib sizes. Its dimensions is 51.6 x 27.2 x 5 inches.

How Much Should You Expect to Pay?

The Classica I from Colgate is quite affordable. You can buy this for as low as $149 on with free shipping. But even without the discounted price, the product is still affordable and well worth the buy at a list price of only $180.

What's in the Box?

The Classica I model is HC515-237F; the package will contain the white Classica I foam mattress from Colgate.

Does It Have A Warranty?

Although Colgate offers ten-year warranty periods for some of its products, this offer does not apply to the Colgate Classica I.

What Consumers are Saying

Over 75% of current owners using the Classica I in their child's crib give this product an impressive 5 star rating. Most frequent comments:

  • Mattress fits very well - snug fitting in the crib
  • Durable and long lasting
  • Baby sleeps well on this mattress - usually through the night
  • Firm and sturdy, yet comfortable for baby
  • Firmess is just right
  • Lightweight - making it easy to put inside the crib or change sheets

Some Considerations to Make

Some parents did find the mattress a bit too firm and didn't feel very comfortable letting their babies sleep on it. The experience, however, may differ from one baby/parent to another.

It is also not one of the organic crib mattresses that are becoming increasingly popular in the market. If you'd rather get an organic product since it is quite a trend these days, then the Classica I is not for you. Colgate does offer an organic version of the product called ECO Classica.

Where and How to Buy

The Colgate Classica I foam crib mattresses is available in selected specialty stores that sell crib mattresses. It is also available at online shopping sites such as which is usually the best place to buy.

Related Pages

Return From Colgate Classica I Foam Crib Mattress Review to Best Mattresses

Return From Colgate Classica I Crib Mattress Review to Mattress Wiz

Popular Pages

Like Mattress Wiz? Please Tell A Friend

Please Take A Quick Poll

What Is Most Important When Buying A New Mattress?
Choose One:
Popular Reviews

Copyright © 2009-2015 | All Rights Reserved. | All trademarks used are properties of their respective owners.